Sir John Valentine Carden Survives. Part 2.

And after aircraft air-frames have had their slice of available aluminium, the ordnance people want aluminium to make their big things (depth charges, aircraft bombs, and so forth) which go 'bang' go 'bang' better.
Depth charges seems a bit silly , you actually want the highest possible density, its why later ones had a lump of solid iron attached. Sink rate for a given shape and size is relative to density, higher the density, higher the sink rate and hence higher chances of the sub still being in the target area when it goes boom ( if you are dropping in the right place to start with of course :) ).
 
Well they wouldn't be paper tigers there at least.
I have a shadow of an idea for a time line where 300 get sent to the Australian army for training purposes and 150 end up in Malaya
I don't know exactly when in 1941 they received the interim fixes to the cooling system, but I know that by November 41 the full rework was tested and Covenanter III was in production in October, both being cleared for tropical conditions. So it might be a little late to deploy them before the Japanese invade but it would be adequate for initial reinforcements to Australia and SEA. However the British didn't do so OTL so either they prioritized the rearmament of units in Britain with the Covvies or they didn't have the shipping to send Covvies when one accounts for all the stuff they sent OTL. Or maybe they didn't have enough imagination in which case sending them is possible yes.

The other scenarios where Covvies may be deployed is in the European front in the event of an ITTL 1942 raid/limited amphibious operation or a 1943 invasion of France since there wouldn't necessarily be enough of the other tanks and Covvies were already in Britain. Another (less likely) possibility is them being used instead of Stuarts in recon units in the ETO, as they are comparable if not a bit better in some areas. The last possibility is more conversions of Covenanter hulls that are deployed in battle. An Archer-type vehicle might be the best option, as it would be considerably more mobile. But since Archers were production vehicles the Covvie conversion would require work to rebuild the front part of the tank.​
 
I don't know exactly when in 1941 they received the interim fixes to the cooling system, but I know that by November 41 the full rework was tested and Covenanter III was in production in October, both being cleared for tropical conditions. So it might be a little late to deploy them before the Japanese invade but it would be adequate for initial reinforcements to Australia and SEA. However the British didn't do so OTL so either they prioritized the rearmament of units in Britain with the Covvies or they didn't have the shipping to send Covvies when one accounts for all the stuff they sent OTL. Or maybe they didn't have enough imagination in which case sending them is possible yes.

The other scenarios where Covvies may be deployed is in the European front in the event of an ITTL 1942 raid/limited amphibious operation or a 1943 invasion of France since there wouldn't necessarily be enough of the other tanks and Covvies were already in Britain. Another (less likely) possibility is them being used instead of Stuarts in recon units in the ETO, as they are comparable if not a bit better in some areas. The last possibility is more conversions of Covenanter hulls that are deployed in battle. An Archer-type vehicle might be the best option, as it would be considerably more mobile. But since Archers were production vehicles the Covvie conversion would require work to rebuild the front part of the tank.​
Well ITTL the Covenanter is long gone, and LMS has been moved on to other projects.
 
It's interesting that they still have CS tanks even when the standard gun was reasonably HE capable.

Edit. But then I remembered that the US had a good HE round for the sherman and also used the 105mm sherman, so other people did the same kind of thing..
In British Army Regiments, by 1944, the Close Support Tanks would have been equipped with the Ordnance QF 95mm Howitzer. To be founds on variants of the Cromwell, Churchill, and the only Centaurs to actually see action, with the Royal Marine Armoured Support Group.
 
6 August 1941. Singapore.
6 August 1941. Singapore.

The arrival of WS9AX the previous day had brought with it the 11th Bn RTR and their 58 A12 Infantry Tanks Mark II. The Battalion had been raised in January 1941 and there had been talk of them training on some kind of secret new weapon. Instead, they had been designated to join the forces reinforcing Malaya and Singapore.

Lieutenant-General Arthur Percival had been somewhat surprised when informed that the War Cabinet had included a Tank Battalion among the reinforcements he was to receive. Some of his staff had doubts about the suitability of the tanks in the terrain, but Percival couldn’t help feeling that he shouldn’t look a gift horse in the mouth. Lt-Col Michael Hedderwick (CO 11th Bn RTR) was formerly introduced to his new Commanding Officer, who was full of questions about the capabilities and limitations of a Tank Battalion.

Lt-Col Hedderwick had been promoted and transferred from 7th Bn RTR, where he’d commanded a squadron of A12s in the battle of Arras (loaned to 4th Bn RTR on the day). Bringing that experience to Malaya Command was going to be a challenge. Hedderwick and his officers had spent long hours on the voyage looking at as much information as they could get their hands on. The questions about the suitability of the ground for tanks would only be fully answered once they were in country and had a chance to reconnoitre the area.

When he had the chance, Hedderwick asked Percival to allow him to do three things in the first month. Firstly, to have a number of his officers and NCOs to make a thorough study of the landscape, particularly after they’d seen the general plan to defend Malaya and Singapore. Secondly, it would take up to a month to make sure that all the tanks were fighting fit. The question of tropicalisation was something of a mystery regarding the Matilda IIs. There would likely be a need for some trial and error to get the tanks, and their crews adapted for the climate and geography. The need for his men to have some kind of rudimentary training in jungle warfare, even it was just to learn which snakes were most dangerous, would be much appreciated.

The third and final request was to keep the Battalion together. What had been learned in the war so far was that splitting tank forces up into penny packets was counter-productive. It had been shown in North Africa that the combination of Infantry Tanks and the Indian and Australian Infantry was very successful. Once everything was organised, Hedderwick’s Adjutant had prepared a training program to offer to the Infantry units on collaboration between tanks, infantry and artillery.

Percival’s Chief of Staff was furious that a Lieutenant-Colonel should have the gall to tell his superior what he wanted. It was up to Malaya Command to find something useful to do with these tanks, and there were plenty of senior officers who had requested some tanks for each of their particular needs. Percival however had read Hedderwick’s file, and knew that he had fought as a young officer at Cambrai in 1917 and again as a Major at Arras in 1940. Percival never had much to do with tanks at any point in his career. His inclination was the same as his Chief-of-Staff, to provide as many units as possible with a troop of tanks. Hedderwick however had made a good case. Percival agreed the first two requests without hesitation. Everyone coming to Malaya needed time to adapt, and tanks were an unknown capability in the country. As to the last request, Percival could see that providing his main infantry Brigades with training on collaborating with tanks would be worthwhile. As to keeping the Battalion together, he couldn’t promise anything, until he had a better notion of just what tanks would be able to do.
 
The arrival of WS9AX the previous day had brought with it the 11th Bn RTR and their 58 A12 Infantry Tanks Mark II. The Battalion had been raised in January 1941 and there had been talk of them training on some kind of secret new weapon. Instead, they had been designated to join the forces reinforcing Malaya and Singapore.

Welp....good luck Japan...your going to need it because now Singapore has a single mighty sledgehammer that's virtually unkillable.
 
Tanks in Singapore and Matilda's too good luck with the IJA getting through them, heck the stop their advance the majorly screw up the Japanese since their logistics is so poor. Still, though this depends a great deal on how the command in Singapore uses them I can't see Percival using them all that effectively though on the other hand more officers who have a working brain out east are always useful.
 
And the Japanese plans for the Southern Resource Area have just gone off the rails, dived over a cliff into a deep crevasse, exploded and set the surrounding area on fire with the burning remains.

Giving the local forces combined arms training using equipment that the Germans had a hard time against is going to make a mess of Japanese infantry attacks. The Matilda might as well be a Centurion for how badly outclassed the Japanese armour will be.

The Commonwealth forces will be well aware of how dangerous the Matilda II is and they'll become the natural focus of the defensive operations.

Is Burma getting similar gear?
 
Last edited:
The Matilda might as well be a Centurion for how badly outclassed the Japanese armour will be.

Hell, I don't even think that the Japanese Battalion Gun, a 70mm HE thrower will be of much use against the Matilda II. I wouldn't be surprised if Matildas could walk off direct hits from the gun, they can take near-misses for sure.
 
If things go off on schedule, they have about 5 months now to complete getting ready. Malay and Singapore may hold, makes it harder for the Japanese in D.E.I. Still the Japanese fleet is yet to be affected much, until we see naval transfers. Even then the Japanese navy is a very nasty threat.
 
Welp....good luck Japan...your going to need it because now Singapore has a single mighty sledgehammer that's virtually unkillable.
If the British can keep the Matilda's running, if they keep them concentrated, if they are in the right place at the right time and if their 2pdr ammunition hasn't deteriorated.
 
I'm not sure you need to keep the tanks concentrated necessarily, as the Japanese have little to nothing that can hurt them.
 
I wonder if the 2pdr might actually have too much penetration against Japanese targets. I don't mean tanks, but infantry and soft vehicles. I suppose a CS field modification to lob HE mortar shells might be possible. They're going to get a lot of use out of the Besa MG in any case.
(edit) I note that CS versions of the Matilda were available, armed with the 3-inch Howitzer, but I'm unsure how many this Singapore force has available to it.

Either way, the Matildas are going to offer Singapore a set of mobile bunkers they can anchor a defensive line around if the commanders are clever enough to realize it.
 
Last edited:
6 August 1941. Singapore.

The arrival of WS9AX the previous day had brought with it the 11th Bn RTR and their 58 A12 Infantry Tanks Mark II. The Battalion had been raised in January 1941 and there had been talk of them training on some kind of secret new weapon. Instead, they had been designated to join the forces reinforcing Malaya and Singapore.

Lieutenant-General Arthur Percival had been somewhat surprised when informed that the War Cabinet had included a Tank Battalion among the reinforcements he was to receive. Some of his staff had doubts about the suitability of the tanks in the terrain, but Percival couldn’t help feeling that he shouldn’t look a gift horse in the mouth. Lt-Col Michael Hedderwick (CO 11th Bn RTR) was formerly introduced to his new Commanding Officer, who was full of questions about the capabilities and limitations of a Tank Battalion.

Lt-Col Hedderwick had been promoted and transferred from 7th Bn RTR, where he’d commanded a squadron of A12s in the battle of Arras (loaned to 4th Bn RTR on the day). Bringing that experience to Malaya Command was going to be a challenge. Hedderwick and his officers had spent long hours on the voyage looking at as much information as they could get their hands on. The questions about the suitability of the ground for tanks would only be fully answered once they were in country and had a chance to reconnoitre the area.

When he had the chance, Hedderwick asked Percival to allow him to do three things in the first month. Firstly, to have a number of his officers and NCOs to make a thorough study of the landscape, particularly after they’d seen the general plan to defend Malaya and Singapore. Secondly, it would take up to a month to make sure that all the tanks were fighting fit. The question of tropicalisation was something of a mystery regarding the Matilda IIs. There would likely be a need for some trial and error to get the tanks, and their crews adapted for the climate and geography. The need for his men to have some kind of rudimentary training in jungle warfare, even it was just to learn which snakes were most dangerous, would be much appreciated.

The third and final request was to keep the Battalion together. What had been learned in the war so far was that splitting tank forces up into penny packets was counter-productive. It had been shown in North Africa that the combination of Infantry Tanks and the Indian and Australian Infantry was very successful. Once everything was organised, Hedderwick’s Adjutant had prepared a training program to offer to the Infantry units on collaboration between tanks, infantry and artillery.

Percival’s Chief of Staff was furious that a Lieutenant-Colonel should have the gall to tell his superior what he wanted. It was up to Malaya Command to find something useful to do with these tanks, and there were plenty of senior officers who had requested some tanks for each of their particular needs. Percival however had read Hedderwick’s file, and knew that he had fought as a young officer at Cambrai in 1917 and again as a Major at Arras in 1940. Percival never had much to do with tanks at any point in his career. His inclination was the same as his Chief-of-Staff, to provide as many units as possible with a troop of tanks. Hedderwick however had made a good case. Percival agreed the first two requests without hesitation. Everyone coming to Malaya needed time to adapt, and tanks were an unknown capability in the country. As to the last request, Percival could see that providing his main infantry Brigades with training on collaborating with tanks would be worthwhile. As to keeping the Battalion together, he couldn’t promise anything, until he had a better notion of just what tanks would be able to do.
Well: the good news for Imperial Japan is they have three months or so until their original timeline offensive for their informants and spies to spot the Matildas and report back to high command.
Although what Imperial Japanese high command does about any reports it receives (and whether anyone double-checks how the things performed for the British in other theatres?) is another matter altogether...
 
Although what Imperial Japanese high command does about any reports it receives (and whether anyone double-checks how the things performed for the British in other theatres?) is another matter altogether...
Which one? Navy and the Army have their own Orgs and don't talk to each other.

Seriously the Japanese high command is highly dysfunctional heck officers on the borders took what IJA Generals said in Tokyo as suggestions more often than not,
 
Last edited:
Top